Making cuts as a beginner can be quite intimidating.
With the potential of collecting methanol in your jars, it can be frustrating to try to understand when to make cuts, considering every home distiller has its own technique for making cuts.
To make cuts, it’s best to use labeled collecting jars and blend afterwards. Use your sense of smell and taste, and take your time to get acquainted with the different characteristic of your distillate at each point in the distillation process. Covering the jars with coffee filters or cheesecloth and letting them sit overnight is also good practice as it allows the harsh chemicals to evaporate, so you know what to discard or keep.
This article discusses how to make cuts when distilling, so you’ll always be confident that you’re only keeping the best possible fractions that come off your still.
First, What Are Fractions?
During distillation, there are parts of the wash collected as you progress from the beginning to the end of your run. These are called fractions.
These portions are called foreshots, heads, hearts, dunder, tails, and feints. The process of dividing fractions is referred to as “making cuts.”
With column distillation, it’s possible to separate out the individual fractions, but with pot distillation they all blend together.
|Methanol (Wood Alcohol)||64 C (147F)|
|Ethyl acetate||77.1C (171F)|
|Ethanol Azeotrope||78.2C (172.8F)|
|2-Propanol (rubbing alcohol)||82C (180F)|
What Do We Mean By Cuts?
Cuts are where you separate the pure from the impure alcohol during distillation – Essentially deciding to keep the stuff you want, and throw away the stuff you don’t. It involves dividing the drinkable, good-tasting portions from those that contain potent parts of alcohol, like methanol and other chemicals.
You might also make cuts to ‘blend’ different flavors into a whiskey or gin for example.
To effectively make cuts, you need to have insight into the different fractions. Experienced distillers can recognize these fractions by smell as the liquid exits the condenser into collecting jars. But it’s easier said than done for new distillers.
Making cuts helps you decipher which distillate you can keep to bottle or recycle for the next run, or which has to be discarded. Because different components of the wash boil at different temperatures, some distillers use thermometers or alcometers to gauge which fraction is dripping into the jars, allowing them to switch containers when the need arises.
Below is a table summarizing the characteristics of fractions and when to collect them according to your thermometer and/or alcoholmeter reading.
|Fraction||Thermometer and/or Alcoholmeter Reading|
|Foreshots||• Boils at 148-175°F (65-79°C). |
• Contains acetone and methanol.
• Collect 50-150ml of this distillate, then discard it or use for general purposes like cleaning glass.
• Smells slightly sweet with undertones of nail polish.
|Heads||• Contains acetone, ethyl acetate, and traces of ethanol.|
• Collect when the thermometer reads 176-196°F (80-91°C).
• Alcometer reads 80-82% ABV
|Hearts||• Purest fraction of the run|
• Start collecting at 80-92% ABV (160 proof) or 197-205°F (°C)
• Clean ethanol smell.
|Tails||• Last part of the distillate. |
• The thermometer reads 205-208°F (96-97°C)
• Alcoholmeter reading drops to about 20% ABV.
|Dunder||• Fraction is left in the boiler after distilling.|
• It’s often poured back into the wash to enhance the flavor of a fresh wash.
|Feints||• The early Tails often recycled in the next batch to extract any good ethanol.|
What Are The Different Distilling Cuts?
Here’s a detailed explanation of cuts.
First of all, it’s important to note that you can use temperature to judge your cut point ONLY when running a well equalised column still. With a pot still, they all blend together, so you’re going to need to rely on your senses to figure out what to keep and what to throw.
This is the first part of the distillate. Foreshots contain methanol and ethyl acetate and are collected when the thermometer reads 148-175°F (65-79°C). This fraction smells slightly sweet with undertones of nail polish.
It’s always discarded or used for general purposes like cleaning glass or lighting fires or BBQs. When making cuts, you’ll typically collect 50-150ml of this distillate for a 20L wash.
These fractions contain ethyl acetate and traces of ethanol. Heads have a pungent alcohol smell. You can recycle this fraction in your next batch or use it for general purposes. When your thermometer reaches ~79C, then you know you’ve reached your heads. You collect about 150ml of this portion.
|Vapor Temp In Pot Still||75-80°C|
|Vapor Temp In Column Still||77-79C|
The hearts are the purest fraction of the run. You’ll know hearts are coming through by the clean smell of ethanol. When you take a tiny sip of this portion, you’ll also pick up notes of your wash. The hearts start exiting your condenser at 79C and due to the volume of the azeotrope, should keep your column locked around 79 – 81 degrees.
|Vapor Temp In Pot Still||Approx 80-95°C|
|Vapor Temp In Column Still||Between 79 and 81C|
Tails are the last part of the distillate. That’s when most of the ethanol is spent and fusel oils start entering your jars. The tails have a funky – wet dog/damp socks, smell. When your thermometer reads 205-208°F (96-97°C), that’s when you start collecting your tails. At this point, the alcometer reading drops to 10-20% ABV and you should stop your run.
|Vapor Temp In Pot Still||96-97°C|
|Vapor Temp In Column Still||>81C|
Also known as backset, dunder is the fraction left in the boiler after distilling. Dunder is usually poured back into the wash to enhance the flavor of a fresh wash, and it’s often used when making rum. This portion is not only used for taste purposes, but it also creates optimal fermentation – balances the pH and acts as a yeast nutrient.
Feints are tails recycled in the next batch.
What’s The Risk Of Making Cuts Wrong?
When you make wrong cuts, you can end up with a collection of harmful chemicals such as methanol. Not only will this produce a vile-tasting spirit, but it could make you ill, blind or potentially kill someone.
Now, the risk of actually producing a dangerous amount of these chemicals is very low, but it’s important to be wary of this. More likely, you’ll just end up producing alcohol that doesn’t taste very nice and no one will want to drink it.
Read more: This article discusses how to minimise the amount of methanol you’re producing.
To Make Cuts In Real-Time Or Not?
As a novice, it can be difficult to detect fractions by simply smelling the distillate as it drips into your jar, so you’re most likely to make wrong cuts in real time. In this instance, we recommend you invest in a bunch of collection jars (I use old pickle jars!) an alcoholmeter, and pay careful attention to the reading on your thermometer.
As you get familiar with the process, your recipe, and the equipment, you can switch to making cuts in real time. For example, for a large batch it’s not very practical to collect in hundreds of little jars..
Tip: I’ve been distilling for years and still struggle to make accurate cuts in real time. Instead, I collect in large flasks and then switch to small cuts-jars when i am nearing the cut point. E.g. I’ll collect in 5 small jars when I’m nearing the start of hearts so i don’t accidentally cut too early an contaminate the whole batch!
How To Make Cuts With A Pot Still
As mentioned earlier in the post, making good cuts with a pot still is HARD. All the fractions blend together and you can easily end up with a nasty-tasting product that is far removed from the clean drink you were hoping for.
Here’s our guide to make cuts on a pot still.
What you’ll need
- 10-20 glass collection jars, labeled from 1 to 20
- A pot still!
Assuming you’ve assembled and run your still according to your user manual, follow these steps to make cuts.
- Place a glass jar at the exit point of your condenser. Collect the first 50-150ml at 148-175°F (65-79°C) – these are the foreshots. Discard or use for general purposes.
- Collect the next 150ml at 176-196°F (80-91°C), these will be your heads. You can throw away this portion or recycle it in the next batch.
- When the heat of your still reaches 197-205°F (91-96°C), switch glasses and collect the hearts.
- When the thermometer reads 205-208°F (96-97°C), you can start collecting the tails. Wait till your alcometer reads 20% ABV, then turn off your still.
- Cover each of the jars with coffee filters or cheesecloth and let them sit overnight.
How To Make Cuts On A Reflux Still
A reflux still produces a purer spirit because the reflux action pre-condenses and condenses the vapors until the volatile substance (ethanol) exits the still – leaving behind impure substances. But, you’ll still need to collect the foreshots
Step 1: Heat-Up
Step 2: Equalising
Step 3: Foreshots
Step 4: Re-Equalising
Step 5: Heads
Step 6: Re-Equalising
Step 7: Hearts
Step 8: Tails
Frequently Asked Questions:
Q1. How much heads do I need to throw away when distilling?
When making a 5-gallon (18 liters) batch, throw away 150ml of your heads, and when making 10 gallons (37 liters), you’ll throw away 300ml.
Q2. Can I recycle heads in the next batch?
You can recycle the heads if there’s a flavor you’re trying to extract. Because heads contain ethyl acetate (and some ethanol), recycling your heads means you’re increasing the amount of ethyl acetate in your next run, and you’ll have more heads cut in the next batch.
Q3. Can I recycle foreshots in the next batch?
You can’t recycle foreshots in your next batch. This fraction contains harmful chemicals like methanol and can cause liver, brain, and eye damage. As tempting as it may be to use them to bump your alcohol volume: never recycle them in your next batch.
When embarking on the home distilling hobby, there are some exciting learning curves you’ll have to overcome – making cuts is one of them. With so many online resources telling you you should rely on your sense of smell, this can be quite daunting if you haven’t yet mastered this skill.
Luckily, there are instruments like alcometers and thermometers that you can utilize to guide you through the whole process. Once you’re comfortable in the distilling craft, you can effectively make cuts in real time without the danger of methanol poisoning.